I'm deep in the imbroglio about John Bayley's books about his wife, Iris Murdoch, and her descent into Alzheimer's. He wrote three books: Elegy for Iris (1999), Iris and Her Friends (2000), and Widower's House (2001.) Better he should have stopped with one. He is frank in exposing every detail of Murdoch's despairing descent into chaos, which is sad and distressing. The story might better have been left untold.
Along came A N Wilson, who knew Iris Murdoch and John Bayley well. Bayley was his tutor at Oxford. Wilson was deeply offended by Bayley's books and the movie made from them. Or at least he said he was in a vituperative book, Iris Murdoch as I Knew Her(2004) in which he accused Bayley of playing the same power games that his wife wrote about so astutely in her novels.
The reviews were just as sharp and as opinionated as Wilson's book. And around and around it went.
Forgotten in all this is the fine work Iris Murdoch did as a philosopher and the exceptional qualities of her novels. She created characters of great charm and intellect and she devised clever and complicated plots that leave the reader shaking her head in admiration.
She was very different from the other, now more popular, women writers of her day, Elizabeth Bowen, Barbara Pym, Elizabeth Taylor. Murdoch's fiction seems to have drifted out of favor. I can only hope that with time it will drift back and be recognized for its exceptional creativity and charm. Perhaps all the hoopla about Bayley's and Wilson's books will entice some people back to the novels that are the basis for all the original interest in the sad end to Iris Murdoch's life.