I tried to read John Banville's Booker-winning novel, The Sea, but I didn't enjoy it and I gave up. I almost did the same thing with his mystery Christine Falls, written under the pseudonym, Benjamin Black.
This is a slow-moving story that begins in Dublin in about 1950. We are introduced to the family of Judge Griffin, his son, Mal, the obstetrician, and his adopted son, Quirke, the pathologist. Mal is married to Sarah and they have a daughter, Phoebe.
It doesn't take long to realize that Sarah and Quirke are in love. Something went very wrong in their youth and Quirke ended up with Sarah's sister who died giving birth to a stillborn child just a year after they were married. Why didn't he marry Sarah? Why did Sarah marry Mal? This is a family with a lot of secrets from the reader.
As the book opens Christine Falls dies giving birth to a baby who is immediately whisked off to America and placed with a working class family in Boston. When Quirke finds his brother-in-law altering her medical record he becomes curious about the girl. How did she die? Why would Mal lie about her death?
He asks a few too many questions and unfortunate things begin happening to him and to the people he talks to. He patches together some of the story, realizing that Christine's baby isn't the only one that has been whisked off to America.
The big mystery is who is the father of whom? There are some interesting developments as paternity is revealed, but there are no surprises. The reader figures out the crux of the matter about 200 pages before Quirke does.
Nonetheless, this is not a bad book. It's not a thriller, and it doesn't require the kind of detecting skills needed to solve the murder in an Agatha Christie novel, but it's interesting, extremely well written, and skillfully put together. There are no coincidences, and nothing is illogical. People act as we expect them to do, given their character, and Black carefully describes character throughout.
This is the first in a series. Despite my disappointment with this book I'm looking forward hopefully to the next book. Black is a fine writer, and I think once he settles down he may become a fine mystery writer.